I know that in the training, Sylvain explains why he stopped using the Coleman multi-row seeder for radishes, because the results were too inconsistent. I was wondering if any of you use or have already used a multi-row seeder for crops like mesclun or arugula? Do you see any advantage over the JP1 for these crops? Or maybe you prefer sowing in trays/plugs rather than direct sowing? I’d love to hear your feedback!
I had a six-row, I sold it. Not very practical. I do everything with the JP1. Except for mesclun and arugula, which I sow by hand so that the whole bed is covered with greens. A sprinkling of castor cake, firming with the back of the rake, and micro-sprinkling. Well, you can’t do industrial quantities of it though…
I used the Coleman for 2 years for mesclun (Asian greens, arugula, mizuna, etc.) and radishes, and clearly since I switched to the JP1 it’s much, much better. More precise settings, no need to have ultra-worked, ultra-fine soil, whereas the Coleman tends to clog and jam if there are little bits of branches, small clods, etc. And with the JP1, by sowing arugula or mizuna in 5 rows, you can keep up with the mesclun crop, which really must not get overrun with weeds.
For radishes, I doubled my yields by switching to the JP1 with the splitting share.
The Coleman is good for sowing in potting soil (finely sieved compost) or without compost, because otherwise it’s very complicated. You can’t sow deep enough for the radish, otherwise it gets blocked by the compost and ends up raking.
The JP1 with a furrow opener base is much better!