My organic certifier tells me I’m required to plant a green manure (excluding legumes) in my rotation cycle on my outdoor beds. How do you all handle this? Does each auditor have their own interpretation? Apart from planting a very short-cycle crucifer like mustard, I don’t really see how to do it… I thought I saw that Sylvain just covers his beds with a tarp in winter…
It sounds like you’ve come across a picky auditor. Personally, I didn’t get this request from mine. Now, if we read the regulations, it says that:
Soil management and fertilization
[…] 1.9.2. Soil fertility and biological activity are preserved and increased in the following way:
a)
except in the case of pastures and perennial forage, through multi-year crop rotation, including mandatory legume crops as a main crop or cover crop for crops in rotation and other green manure crops;
b)
in the case of greenhouses or perennial crops other than forage, through short-term green manure and legume crops, as well as through the use of plant diversity; and
c)
in all cases, through the spreading of livestock effluents or organic matter, preferably composted, from organic production.
I think most auditors consider that our diversified systems with crop rotation and compost/organic matter input are enough to preserve soil fertility.
Now, either you comply and all you have left to do is integrate green manures into your rotations. I knew a market gardener who, having enough space to do so, devoted part of his land to green manures every year…
Or you try to find out from other market gardeners near you whether they are subject to this same requirement, or from the organic agency in your department/region or even the chamber of agriculture to gather arguments you can put forward to your auditor. I don’t know where you stand in terms of your commitment with your certifier, but perhaps you should consider changing if he really is the only one with this requirement?
Thanks a lot for your reply. Yeah, from talking with the local market gardeners, same auditor, same requirements, that’s the impression I get. Then again, they’re working with larger plots, so it’s less restrictive. I’ll sound out some other colleagues with other auditors to see. Talk soon
Hi, I’ve got the same situation with my certifier — he made the same remark to me at the start of the year (I’m with Ecocert and based in the Ardennes). It would indeed be interesting to know the requirements of the other certification bodies, because frankly it’s not that I don’t want to sow any, but when you’re just starting out it’s a lot to manage, I find (I’m not even up to speed on my ITK yet, so managing green manures ), not to mention the time the bed is occupied, the problem of mowing it down afterwards, the potential weed infestation, the cost of the green manure… Then again, if I’m interpreting correctly the article Edwige shared, there’s no obligation to put them everywhere every year, so if for example I put ¼ of the gardens in green manure every year I think that works (I’d planned rye/vetch but the delivery is very late and I’m afraid of sowing it for nothing now given the temperatures around here) — though under cover, apart from sorghum between spring/autumn crops, I’ve got no ideas, and seeing how it apparently grows, I’m telling myself I’ll struggle without a mulcher to turn it into mulch Then again, we’re obliged to integrate it into an overall rotation, but there’s no requirement for the cover crop to succeed so if you sow it but it doesn’t grow, you’re fine certification-wise since you played the game, even though agronomically nothing happened
@Ludivine_Le_Nechet I won’t shout it too loudly, but I’m also with Ecocert, and my auditor doesn’t bother me about that.
I agree that there’s no obligation of result, but the economic question remains: do you really want to spend money for a result that’s nil from an agricultural standpoint?
If we’re in the realm of interpretation, couldn’t we consider the bean as a legume in the sense of a cover crop (CC)? Once harvested, if you leave them in place so the plants play their role as nitrogen fixers, we should be good, right? Then you cover them for the winter.
Personally, I sow a cover crop at the end of summer on the garden that will host my squash in N+1. That way they have time to play their role. Then I crush them (or lay them on the ground), then cover them. Finally, I remove the staples from the junction to open the row and add compost at planting.
@Edwige Thanks for sharing, completely agree on the cost of EV if there’s no agronomic result. As for the rest, I had the same thought: can a failed crop be considered a green manure? As long as there’s biomass and it fits into the rotation, I think it makes sense, but I don’t know if my certifier will be okay with the idea. With my radishes sown too densely, for example, lovely foliage, a really clean bed, but a high rate of splitting and they stayed tiny
Talking to people left and right, it seems to be a new 2024 directive… I hope a good argument will be enough: crop rotation with a diversity of botanical families, legumes within the same cycle. Especially since agronomists like Francis Bucaille are calling green manure into question…